Richmond, Dale Jr., and Kyle Busch
Alright… I’ve watched and read a lot about what happened at Richmond Raceway on Saturday night during the NASCAR race. First off, let me say that yes… I am a big Earnhardt Jr. fan. Let me follow that up with the fact that no, I don’t care for Kyle Busch. But all the flak flying around on the NASCAR website and the rest of the internet about the situation is getting ridiculous.
It all boils down to one simple thing : Kyle Busch sped into, or “gunned” the turn into turn 3. Everyone who reviewed the replays has stated that’s what they saw… even Darrel Waltrip, who is a Busch fanboy in the extreme. I watched the race, and I’ve been watching NASCAR for decades, and as you can see by reading my blog I’ve done a considerable amount of online and offline NASCAR racing with various racing sims… and I know a gunned turn when I see it.
The NASCAR announcers have tried to explain it away as “hard racing”, so have many of the fence sitters and Busch fans.
But irregardless of those opinions, the simple fact remains - Kyle Busch sped into turn 3, and caused the accident that knocked Dale Jr. out of the lead.
For anyone who may not be as familiar with circle track racing, and NASCAR in particular (or who may be newer fans), “gunning” a turn happens when a driver cuts into a turn harder than they should. For some background, there are typically three lines a driver can run on any given track (as a rule). They are the “preferred line”, the “low line”, and the “high line”. The preferred line is the line around the track that any driver will usually run when they are not in traffic or side by side with other cars. This line runs high up against the wall in the straights, then drifts all the way down to the apron in the turns, and then drifts out against the wall again as the driver accelerates out of the turn. This line provides the largest possible angle into the turn and as such allows the driver to maintain speed in the turn. By contrast, the high line is the line run by the “outside” car in traffic. This line is run up against the wall, and in the turn typically at least a car and a half of width from the apron. A driver running this line is usually able to maintain his preferred line speed into and through the turn, but due to the increased distance he has to travel in the turn (by not being down on the apron), he’s actually running a bit slower than he would be if he was running the preferred line. The last is the low line. This line is run by the “inside” car (or cars) in traffic. Typically this is run down the middle of the track in the straights, and up against the apron in the turns. This line is the most difficult to drive (at least, it always has been for me), because the entry into the turn is sharper than the preferred or high line… and thus requires the driver to slow the car (or brake) earlier when entering the turn to keep the car under control. If a driver enters the turn “at speed”, as in, entering at the preferred line or high line speed, the car will drift (or “push”) up the track into the high line until the driver slows the car enough to settle properly into the turn.
This is all simple physics.
A driver usually guns a turn due to a number of different reasons… the most common being stress, or the hope to “get their nose under the car” ahead of them in the turn for a fast exit and a pass during the next straightaway. It is almost always a mistake, and almost always causes an incident. Even if two cars, side by side, are racing to the checkered flag, there is no call for bashing or hitting (i.e., “dirty racing”). The guys running the Sprint Cup are professionals, and they all know when they gun a turn, and the results of it when they push it. Gunning a turn is an irresponsible move, and it’s not done by accident.
Furthermore, racing etiquette has a simple rule regarding passing - It is the responsibility of the passing car to make the pass cleanly. If the passing driver cannot cleanly make the pass, then they should back off until they can. This is just good clean racing etiquette, and helps build a driver’s reputation as a clean race driver… thus gaining the respect of those on the track with him. Drivers who tend to not follow this simple rule of etiquette are not highly thought of, regardless of their skills.
With all these things in mind, the incident at Richmond was simply completely unecessary. Busch had a faster car (or, at least, was running a slighly faster line). There were less than 10 laps left to go, all he had to do was bide his time and wait for a clean pass. Instead, as has been his habit since he started racing in Cup, he tried to force the issue early by “getting his nose under” Earnhardt into the turn, thereby gunning it, and slipping up the track as a result into Earnhardt and knocking him out of the lead. The irony is that by doing so, he also screwed up his own chances of winning the race… and this isn’t the first time Busch has done this and lost a race as a result.
The other side of the question is whether or not Busch meant to hit Earnhardt. While I don’t necessarily think he meant to hit Jr., he did speed into the turn… which clearly indicates one of two possibilities. 1) He didn’t care if he hit Jr. or not, or 2) he was actually trying to hit Jr. My personal opinion is that of #1. I don’t think he was actually trying to hit him, but he obviously wasn’t too concerned if he did… and, his post race interview clearly showed that to be the case, with his typical “it was the other guy’s fault, not mine” attitude.
No, I don’t like Kyle Busch. And yes, I’m an Earnhardt fan. But this isn’t about Earnhardt losing the race because he got knocked out. This is about, as far as I’m concerned, a race driver deliberately gunning a turn rather than being patient, and knocking a guy out of the lead (no matter who the leader was… I’d be just as upset at the situation if the roles were reversed). The incident was no different than Dale Earnhardt Sr.’s infamous win at Bristol when he spun out Ricky Rudd for the win years ago. It’s irresponsible, “dirty” racing… and I don’t care for it, nor for a driver that continually sinks to it. There’s no call for it.
If a driver wants to race that way, then as far as I’m concerned they need to get out of NASCAR and go somewhere else. There’s plenty of smash-em-up derby’s out there… they need to find one and then they can bash to their heart’s content.